Claim 66c6caecChecked 21 Jul 2026
TrueOn the truth scale
“Some people see the European Union as a check on the exercise of unaccountable, undemocratic power in this country.”
Reasoning & Evidence21 Jul 2026
The claim is a soft, hedged assertion: that "some people see the European Union as a check on the exercise of unaccountable, undemocratic power" in the UK. It does not assert that the EU actually *is* such a check, only that the viewpoint exists among some people. This is a very low bar to meet.
Public evidence abundantly confirms that such a perspective exists and has been articulated by pro-European commentators, academics, and politicians. For instance, a 2011 openDemocracy article argued that "European integration has helped [national parliaments] to gain powers over strong executives" and that the root of the UK's democratic deficit "lies in an overwhelmingly strong British executive" — effectively framing EU membership as a counterweight to concentrated, unaccountable domestic executive power. Similarly, pro-EU voices have long argued that EU institutions (such as the European Parliament, the Commission's transparency requirements, and the European Court of Justice) provide external constraints on domestic executive overreach. The UK government's own rhetoric around the European Union Act 2011 acknowledged the "democratic deficit" debate, and the Liberal Democrat wing of the coalition was known for making exactly this kind of argument — that EU membership served as a guarantor of rights and a check on unfettered domestic executive power.
Given that the claim only requires that *some people* hold this view (not that it is correct), and given that this view is well-documented in public discourse around and before the 2011 interview date, the claim is true.
Sources: openDemocracy, "If not the EU, who will Britain blame for its democratic deficit?" (https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/if-not-eu-who-will-britain-blame-for-its-democratic-deficit/); UK in a Changing Europe, "State and nation after Brexit: UK constitution and sovereignty" (https://ukandeu.ac.uk/uk-constitution-after-brexit/); GOV.UK, "Now you have power to veto EU changes in referendum" (https://www.gov.uk/government/news/now-you-have-power-to-veto-eu-changes-in-referendum); LSE European Institute, "European Union Act 2011" by Murkens (https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/48991/1/WPS2013-03_Murkens.pdf)
From article
True, but some of your small shopkeepers might look at the huge supermarket chains and ask: Will any political party ever rein them in? Likewise, Parliament was afraid of News International. Perhaps some people like the European Union because they see it as a check on the exercise of unaccountable, undemocratic power here…
Sources opened
| [1] | opendemocracy.net |
| [2] | eu-rope.ideasoneurope.eu |
| [3] | ukandeu.ac.uk |
| [4] | ucleuropeblog.com |
| [5] | independent.co.uk |
| [6] | legislation.gov.uk |
| [7] | researchonline.lse.ac.uk |
| [8] | gov.uk |
| [9] | gov.uk |
| [10] | ucl.ac.uk |