Claim a2e3b79cChecked 21 Jul 2026
TrueOn the truth scale
“The families have endured grief and trauma since the tragic deaths of their loved ones.”
—Keir StarmerLabourThe Prime Minister·Engagements·03 Jun 2026Factual · historical current chronological
Reasoning & Evidence21 Jul 2026
The claim that "the families have endured grief and trauma since the tragic deaths of their loved ones" is strongly supported by multiple public sources.
First, the coroner's own findings, published by the Judiciary of Northern Ireland, explicitly acknowledge this. In Chapter 1 of his findings, Mr Justice Scoffield noted "common themes of profound familial loss, long standing grief, lack of contemporaneous investigative support and the enduring impact of the deaths upon surviving family members."
Second, family members have publicly and repeatedly described their grief and trauma over the decades since the 1972 killings:
- Margaret Gargan's brother Harry Gargan said the verdict of "unjust killing will never end the decades of grief and trauma inflicted on our family" and stated "for 54 years you never thought you were going to get anywhere."
- Patrick Butler's granddaughter Natasha said "It's taken 54 years of long, hard fighting to get to this point," and referenced her grandmother who "started this fight to find out answers."
- Patrick Butler's daughter Jacqueline said "after a lifetime of fighting" her father was "finally declared innocent."
- The Butler family described "a lie that has burdened three generations of our family."
The five individuals — Father Noel Fitzpatrick, Patrick Butler, Margaret Gargan, David McCafferty, and John Dougal — were killed on 9 July 1972 in the Springhill/Westrock area of Belfast by British Army soldiers. The initial inquest in 1973 returned open verdicts, and it was not until fresh inquests were directed in 2014 (concluding in April 2024) that the families received a formal finding that the force used was "not reasonable." The decades-long wait for an adequate investigation itself compounded the families' suffering, as the coroner noted.
This is not a private or unverifiable claim about internal states of mind; it is a well-documented fact corroborated by both the official inquest findings and extensive public testimony from the families themselves.
Sources:
- Judiciary NI, Summary of findings – Springhill inquests (https://www.judiciaryni.uk/files/judiciaryni/2026-04/Summary%20of%20findings%20-%20Springhill%20inquests.pdf)
- BBC News, "Prime minister apologises to Springhill families over 1972 shootings" (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn0plqkgjdno)
- BBC News, "Soldiers 'overreacted' when they shot five people dead, judge says" (https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4g8qd1w053o)
- Judiciary NI, Springhill Inquest page (https://www.judiciaryni.uk/springhill-inquest)
From speech
May I also pay tribute to Lord Haselhurst? I know he will be deeply missed, particularly on the Benches opposite. The findings of the recent Springhill inquest into the tragic deaths, in July 1972, of Father Noel Fitzpatrick, Patrick Butler, Margaret Gargan, David McCafferty and John Dougal are sobering. While the circumstances in which the events occurred were undoubtedly challenging, it is the duty of the state to hold itself to the highest standard. The Government accept and deeply regret these findings, and recognise their gravity. On behalf of the Government, I apologise unreservedly to the families for what happened and for the grief and trauma they have endured since the tragic deaths of their loved ones. I also place on record our deepest condolences to the family of Lance Corporal James Freeman, who died in a tragic accident on Sunday. I am also aware of a Royal Navy helicopter crash this morning in Devon. This will be a deeply worrying time for the families, and more information will be set out as soon as possible. Henry Nowak’s family have shown extraordinary dignity after their son’s life was stolen in appalling circumstances. He was clearly a kind, thoughtful and much-loved young man. There are serious questions to answer, including how accusations of racism informed police thinking, and we are supporting the Independent Office for Police Conduct to get to the bottom of what happened. But no matter the pain we feel, there is no justification for more violence and disorder. The attacks directed towards police officers in Southampton last night were disgraceful and completely unacceptable. This is a time for serious work, not rage. Let me be clear: we will ensure that anyone found engaging in disorder meets the full force of the law, as we have done before. This morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in this House, I shall have further such meetings later today.
Sources opened
| [1] | judiciaryni.uk |
| [2] | judiciaryni.uk |
| [3] | judiciaryni.uk |
| [4] | irishnews.com |
| [5] | bbc.com |
| [6] | bbc.co.uk |
| [7] | bbc.co.uk |
| [8] | bbc.com |