Claim 2f2b0245Checked 21 Jul 2026
TrueOn the truth scale
“The speaker and the hon. Gentleman are united in believing that the poison of antisemitism must be fought wherever it is found.”
Interpreted asmetaphor
“The speaker and the hon. Gentleman both believe antisemitism must be opposed everywhere.”
Reasoning & Evidence21 Jul 2026
The claim is that Keir Starmer and the "hon. Gentleman" (the MP who asked the question) both believe antisemitism must be opposed everywhere.
From the Westminster Brief record of the 3 June 2026 debate, the questioner (Q9) — referred to as "the hon. Gentleman" — opened by stating: "I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to combat antisemitism" and went on to describe a series of antisemitic incidents and ask for stronger government action, concluding that "The Jewish people of this country want to feel safe on our streets, in their homes and in our country." The questioner's own words clearly demonstrate a strong belief that antisemitism must be combated.
Starmer's extensive public record on antisemitism is well-documented, including his remarks at the No10 Tackling Antisemitism Forum on 5 May 2026 (available on GOV.UK), where he stated antisemitism is "a poison" and described his government's comprehensive plan to eradicate it "from every corner of society." He has repeatedly used the phrase "fight the poison of antisemitism wherever it is found."
The claim is about a shared belief. While beliefs are internal states, in this case both speakers have publicly and repeatedly expressed the view that antisemitism must be opposed everywhere — the questioner through his detailed question demanding action against antisemitism, and Starmer through his consistent public statements and policy actions. The questioner's own words in Parliament directly confirm his opposition to antisemitism. Starmer's statement that "we are united in our belief" on this specific point is well-supported by the available public evidence.
Sources: Westminster Brief, debate of 3 June 2026 (https://westminsterbrief.co.uk/archive/debate/3-june-2026/engagements-7cc0); GOV.UK, Prime Minister's remarks at No10 Tackling Antisemitism Forum, 5 May 2026 (https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/prime-ministers-remarks-at-no10-tackling-antisemitism-forum-5-may-2026); BBC News, "All of society must tackle 'crisis' of antisemitism, Keir Starmer says" (https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/czd2l55d1e7o); Jewish News, "Starmer: I will always fight for the security, safety, and freedom of British Jews" (https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/starmer-i-will-always-fight-for-the-security-safety-and-freedom-of-british-jews/)
From speech
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question, and we are united in our belief that we must fight the poison of antisemitism wherever it is found. We are investing more to keep Jewish communities safe, with more police patrols and greater security at schools and synagogues; investing £7 million to tackle antisemitism within our universities; and bringing in proscription-like powers to clamp down on malign state activity. We will set out further steps in coming days, and I will make sure the hon. Gentleman is fully informed of the steps we are taking.
Sources opened